Many folk dont believe that affirmative action is right, because it suggests that a race needs more help than the other. Affirmative action programmes must focus on steps which optimise the public services human and financial resources. Arguments for and against affirmative action essay example. There are pros and cons to the policy, though it remains to be seen which side outweighs the other. The purpose of this paper is to argue that affirmative action is not reverse discrimination, but simply a policy to contribute to diversity in the workforce as a matter of distributive justice to the diverse groups in society. Does affirmative action on campus do more harm than good. It addresses the two recent cases decided before the u. Affirmative action is a way to help compensate for the fact that, due to many years of oppression, some races started late in the race. That is the reason affirmative action was birthed by lyndon b. The federalist society and black law students association have come together to change this by cosponsoring a moderated debate between two. Negative action versus affirmative action university of michigan. Left to their own devices, americans will merge and melt. Supreme court concerning the university of michigans policy.
Under a variety of names affirmative action, positive discrimination, reverse. This document can be made in alternative formats by contacting mn. Creating preferences for women and minorities results in reverse discrimination. Therefore article 232 addresses the issue of affirmative action by stating that nothing contained in article 10 of the constitution shall prevent parliament from.
Affirmative action refers to a body of policies and procedures designed to eliminate discrimination against marginalized groups including ethnic minorities, and. The affirmative action debate introduction affirmative action has become a prominent issue in the 1996 presidential campaign and in legislatures, court rooms and newsrooms across the country. There are many benefits to affirmative action that have supported it in being the fundamental national policy it is today. Aug 15, 2011 although i mentioned blacks and other people of color, this concern of controllability is almost exclusively used for blacks and it is especially so for black males. Understanding affirmative action 589 ethnicity or race as equal in historical importance to other dimensions of diversity such as social class. Affirmative action debate, what are some major arguments against aa. Affirmative action refers to a body of policies and procedures designed to eliminate discrimination against marginalized groups including ethnic minorities, and women.
Colleges that use race as a factor in admissions say the approach creates opportunity for students who might otherwise be excluded. Psychological data and the policy debates over the last decade, affirmative action has becom e an increasingly controversial policy within the united states. But, reply those who oppose affirmative action, ranges, targets, and goals amount to quotas in the end because they require employees and school administrators to move toward proportions numerically defined. Affirmative action allows race, color, religion, gender, sexual orientation or national origin to be taken into consideration when making decisions involving the use to public funds. Affirmative action is more of an ethical and moral policy, as opposed to a set system like a quota system. Id be lying if i said the book was balancedit is definitely more pro affirmative action than con, but from the compiler did do a good job collecting essays from opponents who were minorities such as glenn c. That seems to be the burning question in the debate over affirmative action in college admissions. Learn the effects affirmative action bans have had in different states and whether racebased preferences have a future in the united states. Two sides of the affirmative action debate in college.
A society where individuals are judged upon merit, as opposed to the color of their skin. Similarities between the eu and us concept of affirmative action european countries use the term positive action, but no precise definition of positive action exists in the eu too. The need to compensate for what the minorities werent given in the beginning of their life, and for the challenges they face. They combine exceptionally strong symbols with remarkable simplicity. This is not to say that there is no excellence among rewarded whites. What people get wrong about affirmative action cnn. Oct 31, 2014 the federalist society and black law students association have come together to change this by cosponsoring a moderated debate between two knowledgeable and actively engaged attorneys to directly. Current issues involving affirmative action and higher education. Communication the purpose of affirmative action policies and programmes must be fully communicated to all public servants. Affirmative action involves steps being taken to increase the representation of women and minorities in areas of employment, education, and business from which they have been historically excluded. Nov 05, 2017 that seems to be the burning question in the debate over affirmative action in college admissions.
Affirmative action has unnecessarily spread to sports where politics should not be relevant. The affirmative action debate 1760 words 123 help me. By reducing the cost of education, it favors longer studies in the cost. It is thus opportune to take stock, not only of the. I have found myself pondering why college admissions factor so much weight on race or ethnicity and whether or not it is fair. The active integration of marginalized groups into mainstream academic institutions more fairly distributes opportunity, access and power. The writers of the namibian constitution perceived a need for affirmative action as a necessary condition for bringing about change in a previously discriminatory society. Affirmative action, gender equity and university admissions. Discover the pros and cons of the practice and who benefits from it most in college admissions.
They offer the following reasons why affirmative action should be eliminated. Colleges that use race as a factor in admissions say the approach creates. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Affirmative action in the united states and the european union. Therefore, the position i am taking is that affirmative action is ethically and morally good. Current issues involving affirmative action and higher. Affirmative action can involve goals and timetables while avoiding quotas. Essay the affirmative action debate affirmative action defined affirmative action can be defined as positive steps taken to increase the representation of women and minorities in areas of employment, education, and business from which they have been historically excluded standford encyclopedia of. As with the affirmative action debate, the truth here could be denied only through closing ones eyes to the continued practice of racism at institutional levels. That is also the reason that proposition 209 was voted. Sterrett abstract this article examines current issues regarding affirmative action in todays institutions of higher learning. Access, gender equity and affirmative action in all three countries affirmative action has been used to increase womens access to university.
The affirmative action debate most americans desire a colorblind society. Affirmative action in higher education the college dean famed for putting the duke university english department on the map exposes the flaws in the nine arguments commonly used against affirmative action. The following pages will take a multifaceted approach to the affirmative action debate. Pdf critical race theorists have long accepted the interest convergence dilemma as indispensable in discussions of civil rights in the united. This paper analyzes important arguments from each side of the affirmative action debate, including those relating to its constitutionality, and ultimately finds that affirmative action helps society more than it hurts it. Affirmative action and equal protection in higher education congressional research service r45481 version 2 updated 1 introduction the last several years have seen renewed debate over the role that race plays in higher educationa debate over affirmative action. This is reflected in data from the uk oxford and cambridge universities the top academic institutions take more than 50% of their students from private schools, despite private schools. Two types of affirmative action programs utrecht university. Participation affirmative action programmes must be developed with the active participation of. For instance, eva paterson, executive director of the lawyers committee for civil rights, was a beneficiary of affirmative action, and is today one of the main supports of equal educational opportunities.
Finally there are various affirmative action policies in education. Decades after the introduction of racebased preferences in america, the affirmative action debate continues. Coalition to defend affirmative action provides the latest chapter in the nations ongoing debate about racial preferences. Times have changed discrimination is less prevalent violates ideals of colorblind public policies socially and politically divisive aa has not made things better benefits racial minorities from upper middle classes. The success of affirmative action is evident with gender, but, as is also clear, that is the case primarily with white women. It is to say that, as with every group, high performance is by definition a virtue of those who are devoted and.
Affirmative action is required for equality of opportunity. Affirmative action gives minority groups, such as women, equal access to publicly funded programs and contracts. Some positive aspects of affirmative action include. Most of the time, the effectiveness and appropriateness of. Ask students to read ten myths about affirmative action before the next class period. The justifications and limits of affirmative action. That is also the reason that proposition 209 was voted for in 1996.
Affirmative action allows the best to rise by countering systemic exclusion affirmative action actually ensures that, on average, the best candidate is selected precisely because affirmative action systematically includes individuals from groups that are otherwise systematically excluded affirmative action makes race only a small plus for candidates. The theories combine together to prelimit the policy analysis in chapter. The affirmative action debate collects the leading voices on all sides of this crucial dialogue. Employment equity, affirmative action and managing diversity. The new logic of affirmative action duke law scholarship. The regents of the university of california, one of the most renowned universities in the world, voted to. Aug 02, 2017 with rumors swirling about a white houseled challenge to affirmative action practices, its time to revisit what you think you know. Under the status quo, it is easier for students who go to better schools to get into university.
Comparison and analysis 829 b the european union 1. To help students reach an accurate understanding of affirmative action and equal opportunity policies. Affirmative action in south africa repository home. Affirmative action, both for its intended beneficiaries and for society more broadly.
Affirmative action on campus does more harm than good all. Supporters of affirmative action typically endorse goals, but back away from quotas. Affirmative action and equal protection in higher education. Affirmative action provides equal opportunity to underprivileged minorities, but it also leads to irrational decisionmaking based on ethnicity, sex or other unrelated capability factors. The end of discrimination affirmative action both supported and opposed as an answer to racial inequality. Current issues involving affirmative action and higher education by william m. Development approaches and legislative requirements 64 figure 3. Affirmative action is a strong step to equalize the playing field.
Pdf affirmative action is a controversial and often poorly. The pros and cons of affirmative action essay sample. Why affirmative action is needed supporters have offered many reasons why affirmative action is necessary and important. Women fall under the rubric of affirmative action as well. Id be lying if i said the book was balancedit is definitely more proaffirmative action than con, but from the compiler did do a good job collecting essays from opponents who were minorities such as glenn c. Two high achieving asian american students exemplify both sides of that story. Thus, an examination of affirmative action must look at discrimination from all sides, in the third dimension. Essay the affirmative action debate affirmative action defined affirmative action can be defined as positive steps taken to increase the representation of women and minorities in areas of employment, education, and business from which they have been historically excluded standford encyclopedia of philosophy. Affirmative action in south africa does more harm than good. The belief that it is possible to draw a meaningful distinction between goals and quotas is found on both sides of the affirmative action debate. Affirmative action is needed to overcome past injustices or eliminate the effects of those injustices. Affirmative action was the topic of debate leading up to the midterm elections as students at michigan state university in east lansing have been rallying for and against the michigan civil rights.
Affirmative action debate and economics essay 2423 words. Introduction the year 2009 marked 10 years since south africas affirmative action aa legislation of 1998 took effect. Creating preferences for women and minorities results in. Affirmative action as a college student, i am very familiar with the grueling process of filling out countless college applications, writing essay after essay, and checking an assortment of boxes asking you questions such as your parents income and your race. The book is called the affirmative action debate because their are divergent views expressed on the topic in the book. With rumors swirling about a white houseled challenge to affirmative action practices, its time to revisit what you think you know. While this thesis is supportive of affirmative action, it also takes seriously the. Executive order 10925 issued in 1961 introduced the phrase. A short essay which contains the typical arguments for affirmative action arguments against affirmative action.
Unless affirmative action really is inherently preferential, it cannot make use of this spurious construct of equality. Making sense of the affirmative action debate author. It services human resources office at 6512012270 or. Pdf argumentative essay affirmative action 1 sheila. Affirmative action in south africa does more harm than. Assessing the differences article pdf available in international journal of manpower 1745. The roots of affirmative action in employment lie in a set of executive orders issued by u. Affirmative action is necessary to redress past racial injusticesand their ongoing effectsand to fight the present forms of discrimination that pervade society today. Pdf employment equity, affirmative action and managing. The implementation of affirmative action in higher.
Anecdotes, autobiographies, and armchair philosophizing about af. A provocative range of politicians, researchers, legal experts, and businesspeople dispute the best way to fight discrimination. When those steps involve preferential selectionselection on the basis of race, gender, or ethnicityaffirmative action generates intense. Affirmative action on campus does more harm than good.
300 1370 390 546 685 1619 1569 506 870 1670 1184 956 1390 1367 682 694 1147 405 992 1197 219 1551 123 600 441 1310 787 1622 506 1391 360 656 1419 227 661 1341 122